Rethinking Schools: Making Black Lives Matter in Our Schools

This week I subscribed to Rethinking Schools magazine and chose an article entitled Making Black Lives Matter in Our Schools.
This article begins by talking about injustices towards Blacks that have happened recently and how those injustices affect the Black community, including the young black students we teach in schools.
The article discusses how public many schools in the U.S. reinforce racist messages through their curriculum that tells history from the point of view of people with privileged status and through "no excuses" discipline policies.
One part of the article mentioned how New Jersey passed a bill requiring schools to teacher
children how to interact with police "in a manner marked by mutual
cooperation and respect.” This struck me while reading. It reminded me once again of the the scene in the movie The Hate You Give where the father had to teach his young children how to interact with the police so that they stay safe. The editors pose the question, why are we not holding the police accountable for their “regular
murdering of Black and Brown people across the country.” Instead we are putting the responsibility of these injustices on the victims instead of the perpetrators; similar to how some people say women shouldn't be out late at night or they shouldn't drink too much in order to help prevent sexual assaults. We should be holding the police (or men in regards to sexual assaults) more accountable in order to stop these injustices from happening. There needs to be a shift in thinking; from the privileged perspective to one that comes from those being oppressed.
There was also a quote that I chose from this article that I think summarizes a lot of what is going on in American society right now:
“The racist rhetoric of the Trump administration has
provided license for police and white supremacists to escalate their attacks on
Black people and in other communities of color. As a result, many students
across the country will likely be returning to the classroom this fall carrying
the pain and confusion borne of the racist events of the summer.”
I feel very strongly about what the quote is saying. Even though the first sentence of this quote is important and upsets me deeply because of the truth that lies behind it, it is the second sentence of this quote that is important to us teachers. We need to be aware that the current state of society, is going to affect the young Black and Brown students that we teach. We need to be aware of this and use this as discussion points in our classroom. We can use the feelings, pain, and confusion of our students as a catalyst to helping teach our students about power and privilege in our society. We need to be in-tune with our students and how they are affected by what happens in the broader society in order create discussions regarding race and power, and empower a Black Lives Matter at School sentiment.
This is also essentially what the editors of this article argue. The editors argue that we (teachers/schools) need to work towards creating anti-racist, pro-justice pedagogy and curriculum. We need to make our classrooms safe havens for children of color to feel safe and teach and discuss with them the history and struggles of Blacks throughout history from a non-privileged point of view. We cannot be afraid to say the words, as Johnson (2001) would argue, when discussing race, power, history, and current events with our students. The editors also argue that teachers and schools need to act as advocates for students, and people within the community, not in the culture of power in order to, again, be an advocate for Black Lives Matter.
"[It] is both about helping Black students feel valued and connected to their learning as well as about all of us learning from the central struggles for justice when injustice is regularly front-page news. As the current movement phrases it, 'all lives will matter, when Black lives matter.'"
Well written about the article you chose...I wish I had seen this one! It makes me now want to watch that movie The Hate You Give as soon as I find some free time...I have the same feelings about that quote you shared, of how the rhetoric of the Trump administration is fueling the racism and hate in our country, and that people don't feel they need to hold back in their offensive actions. That is a scary pill to swallow. We now have to work even harder than ever to reverse this mindset, and continue our demands for racial justice and equity. Teachers are the role models these students of color see more than anyone on a given day, so they are charged with a huge responsibility to value them and give them the learning opportunities they deserve. Excellent job!!
ReplyDeleteI will have to look this article up. Sounds interesting Erin. It must be frustrating for black students (Native Americans as well as Mexican Americans) to sit in American schools and be indoctrinated by a curriculum that "reinforces racist messages." I can't imagine how that must feel. We do need to work towards a curriculum that is inclusive and actually tells the truth and not one that serves the agenda of white privilege. I firmly believe we have to advocate for our students in all aspects. We need to teach them to have a voice as well and let them use it. I do have to say though as a mother to a police officer, the language used against police officers can be extremely polarizing. We can not generalize a whole group of people based on the actions of some. And... I am not putting the blame on any victim, however I think having a little knowledge about the appropriate way to handle a traffic stop goes a long way. Maybe it shouldn't be a part of the curriculum in our schools, but could be part of DMV education. Every time my son pulls someone over is a chance that he could die. Why not help make their job easier by being compliant with their directions? There is a time and a place to argue and that time is not at a traffic stop. I know that if I am pulled over, my hands are on the wheel and I do not reach for documentation until instructed to do so. I also know I am not supposed to get out of my car without being instructed to do so. Disregarding instructions from the police puts everyone at risk. If people have a problem with why they are pulled over they can voice their objections while still following directions. If the officer isn't listening then take it up in court.
ReplyDeleteI agree that curriculums should incorporate anti-racist and pro-justice lessons for teachers to teach. I believe this will help guide instructors into discussing topics most are not used to discussing. Once we start the conversation, it's not taboo. Instead, students and teachers will become comfortable using language the brings awareness to those oppressed.
ReplyDelete(I too have been taught how to respond to officers of the law. My husband and I have also discussed the same with our children.)
I definitely support the notion of changing school curriculums to represent anti-racist and pro-justice lessons. Especially in the elementary schools. Young children are much more open to change than adults and it is always a good thing to start early. I read Denise's comments about teaching individuals how to properly address mannerism when dealing with cops. Again, it goes back to our class discussions in which the culture in power has made the rules of how to act and expect others to follow, but if you don't know the rules that need to follow, is it any wonder you can easily break them? I agree with Denise that perhaps it should be taught at Driving School more so than at an academic school.
ReplyDeleteHi Erin,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading about the article that you selected this week. It really goes hand in hand with the conversation we had last class regarding the podcast. I like the connection you made between the New Jersey bill and the movie The Hate You Give. Another connection I can make is with the show Good Girls, one of the main characters is an African American woman and in some parts of the show it highlights how her and her husband raise their children. In a conversation the parents, who are both African American, were having with each other, they were discussing having ‘the conversation’ with their son about interactions with the police and how to navigate that. As I watched the show I thought about my own privilege and how I don’t need to worry about situations with the cops. It truly is a shame that situations between individuals of color and police officers are the way that they are and that there isn’t more being done about it.
If this text was interesting to you, I highly recommend the new(ish) book that Rethinking Schools published called Teaching for Black Lives (https://www.teachingforblacklives.org/). It has lots of relevant chapters. And I want to make one comment about the traffic stop conversation here... of course we have to teach all people, though especially kids of color, how to engage in a respectful way at a traffic stop. But the concerns that the BLM movement raises are about the fact (per a very length set of sad statistics) that many Black folks who comply diligently with protocols have still ended up dead. It is about more than being appropriate and compliant. Because our culture has taught us to fear Black people, particularly black men, a simple traffic stop can turn very dangerous for young (men) of color very quickly. Glad that you chose this article to help us all think about these issues.
ReplyDelete